Samyang 45mm f/1.8 vs Sony 50mm f/1.8
Samyang 45mm f/1.8 vs Sony 50mm f/1.8
When it comes to affordable prime lenses for Sony mirrorless cameras, two options frequently enter the discussion: the Samyang 45mm f/1.8 and the Sony 50mm f/1.8. Both lenses are compact, lightweight, and budget-friendly, making them appealing to beginners and enthusiasts alike. Yet, choosing between them can be difficult since they share similar specifications while offering distinct advantages.
This article compares the two lenses in terms of design, image quality, performance, and usability, helping you decide which one fits your photography style.
Compact Prime Lenses for Everyday Use
The appeal of small prime lenses lies in their simplicity. A fixed focal length teaches photographers to compose more thoughtfully, while a wide aperture provides creative control with depth of field and low-light shooting. Both the Samyang 45mm f/1.8 and Sony 50mm f/1.8 deliver these qualities, making them excellent starting points for portraits, street photography, and everyday shooting.
For beginners stepping up from kit lenses or exploring photography beyond a new vlogging camera, either of these primes offers an affordable way to enhance image quality without overwhelming complexity.
Design and Build
The Samyang 45mm f/1.8 is slightly wider than the Sony 50mm, but the difference is subtle in practice. What stands out is its modern design, lighter weight, and comfortable handling. It feels balanced on smaller mirrorless bodies, making it a natural fit for everyday use and travel.
On the other hand, the Sony 50mm f/1.8 carries a more traditional look. While functional, it is a little bulkier and less refined in build compared to newer lens designs. Its focus mechanism is also known to be slower and noisier than many alternatives, which can affect usability for video shooters.
Autofocus Performance
Autofocus is often a deciding factor between these two lenses. The Samyang 45mm f/1.8 benefits from newer technology, offering smoother and quieter autofocus that performs well for both photography and video. This makes it more versatile, especially for hybrid shooters who alternate between stills and motion.
The Sony 50mm f/1.8, while capable, struggles with slower focus acquisition, particularly in low light. For casual use this may not be a dealbreaker, but for fast-moving subjects or critical video work, it can feel limiting.
Image Quality and Rendering
Both lenses are sharp when stopped down, though their wide-open performance reveals differences. The Samyang 45mm f/1.8 produces pleasing sharpness at f/1.8 with minimal distortion and good contrast. Its rendering has a natural look that appeals to portrait and lifestyle photographers.
The Sony 50mm f/1.8 also delivers sharp images, though some softness is noticeable at wide apertures, particularly toward the edges of the frame. However, its classic 50mm perspective remains popular for portraits, offering a flattering compression and background separation.
Both lenses produce smooth background blur, but the Samyang tends to render bokeh with slightly rounder highlights, while the Sony leans more toward a traditional, slightly busier look depending on the shooting conditions.
Low-Light Shooting
A fast aperture like f/1.8 allows both lenses to perform well in dim environments. Whether shooting indoor events, evening portraits, or city streets at night, either lens provides enough light-gathering ability to avoid excessive ISO noise.
The Samyang’s more reliable autofocus in low light gives it an advantage, making it easier to lock onto subjects when conditions are challenging. The Sony can still deliver, but it may require more patience when shooting in darker scenarios.
Everyday Practicality
For everyday photography, both lenses are small enough to carry anywhere. The Samyang’s slightly wider 45mm field of view can feel more natural for casual shooting, as it sits between the standard 50mm and the wider 35mm range. This makes it versatile for portraits, street photography, and even travel.
The Sony 50mm retains its classic role as a portrait lens. While less flexible for general use, it shines when you want subject separation and that timeless look associated with 50mm primes.
For creators experimenting with hybrid setups, such as pairing these lenses with lightweight stabilizers or even compact DJI Cameras, the Samyang often feels more balanced and adaptable thanks to its smoother autofocus and lighter weight.
Which One Should You Choose?
The decision between the Samyang 45mm f/1.8 and Sony 50mm f/1.8 largely depends on priorities. If you want a modern design, faster autofocus, and slightly more versatility for both photography and video, the Samyang is the stronger choice. Its balance of performance and usability makes it a favorite among beginners and enthusiasts alike.
If, however, you prefer the classic 50mm look and primarily shoot portraits or controlled settings where autofocus speed is less critical, the Sony 50mm remains a dependable option. Its long-standing popularity reflects its ability to deliver strong results, even if it feels dated compared to newer alternatives.
Final Thoughts
Both the Samyang 45mm f/1.8 and Sony 50mm f/1.8 offer excellent value for photographers looking to explore fast prime lenses. While the Samyang edges ahead with its modern features and smoother performance, the Sony continues to hold appeal as a traditional portrait lens.
Ultimately, both choices open the door to creative photography without requiring a large investment. They prove that sharp, beautiful images are possible even with compact and affordable lenses. For anyone stepping into the world of primes, either lens can serve as an inspiring companion on the journey toward stronger visual storytelling.
Comments
Post a Comment